If you believe in the importance of free speech, subscribe to support uncensored, fearless writing—the more people who pay, the more time I can devote to this.
Please subscribe to receive at least three pieces /essays per week with open comments. It’s $6 per month, less than USD 4. And now take 50% off (until Aug. 31)
Everyone says, "Hey, it’s just a cup of coffee," but please choose my coffee when you come to the Substack counter. Cheers.
The West has always feared explosions when it should have feared whispers. Bombs at least announce themselves; narratives — planted quietly and patiently — corrode institutions from within. The Muslim Brotherhood, founded in Egypt in 1928, understand this better than anyone.
The true war is not waged with suicide belts but with ideas, bureaucracies, and the exploitation of liberal naïveté. Western democracies, desperate to advertise tolerance, end up reciting the Brotherhood’s script almost verbatim.
Canada prides itself on civility and moderation. We apologise compulsively. We congratulate ourselves on being immune to the convulsions of Europe and the extremism of our southern neighbour. Yet this self‑image renders Canada peculiarly vulnerable to the Brotherhood’s quiet campaign.
Investigations by the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy (ISGAP) show how Brotherhood‑linked entities — the Muslim Association of Canada, Islamic Relief Canada, and the National Council of Canadian Muslims — have woven themselves into civic life, laundering political Islam through the language of multiculturalism and human rights.
Ottawa, dazzled by diversity, partners with them on refugee programs even as Egypt and the UAE blacklist their international affiliates for financing Hamas.
But the decisive battle is not waged in Parliament; it is fought in classrooms and lecture halls. Canadian universities have become laboratories for Brotherhood‑inspired activism — well‑financed, highly coordinated, and relentlessly hostile to dissent. They do not need to proclaim antisemitism; they only need to enforce it by punishing those who defend Israel and indulging those who call for its eradication.
Pro‑Hamas slogans — “from the river to the sea,” glorifications of October 7 — echo unpunished across campuses. Faculty who propagate medieval blood libels about “Zionist child‑killers” remain untouched. Meanwhile, a single sentence of solidarity with Israel can annihilate an academic career.
Why this indulgence? Partly demographics. In Canada, at some institutions, Muslim students outnumber Jewish students roughly ten to one. Universities, obsessed with enrollment targets and international tuition revenue, are acutely sensitive to majoritarian pressures. Administrators know that alienating pro‑Palestinian activists risks unrest and reputational harm; defending Jewish or Zionist voices promises no such benefit.
The fill‑rate calculus incentivises cowardice. One administrator admitted privately: “There are more Palestinian flags than Canadian flags on convocation day — do the math.”
Adding insult, the very offices tasked with upholding equity — human rights offices — have sometimes become political instruments. They can function less as an arbiter of fairness than as an enforcer of prevailing ideological orthodoxy: pro‑Muslim grievance in, pro‑Israel dissent out.
This is the grotesque inversion at the University of Guelph‑Humber in Toronto: the human‑rights office — custodian of fairness in name only — stood idle as faculty flooded social media with anti‑Jewish bile, turned classrooms into recruitment cells, and linked official university social accounts to sites peddling the same poison.
The university even aided students who turned convocation into a rally, hijacking the stage to unfurl a massive Palestinian flag mid‑ceremony. And yet the only one gagged, defamed, shunned, subjected to deliberate character assassination, and ultimately fired was the lone heretic whose sole “crime” was speaking a historical truth: Hamas are Nazis.
Thus, the wardens of “equity” become praetorians of bigotry, sanctifying fanaticism while crucifying dissent.
Comparable patterns are evident in U.S. universities, where Title VI offices, ostensibly designed to combat antisemitism, have been captured by anti‑Israel partisans who redefine “harassment” to exclude anti‑Jewish vitriol while including criticism of Hamas.
To understand the Muslim Brotherhood’s rise, you must trace its roots—and its ideological alignment. Hassan al-Banna’s Ikhwān was not born of pure piety but was shaped in the European totalitarian mould and actively courted Nazi support.
During the late 1930s and early 1940s, Brotherhood leaders maintained contact with Nazi agents in Cairo, receiving funds and republishing anti-Jewish screeds—from Goebbels’ conspiracy theories to paeans to Hitler as divine bane of Zionism.
The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Haj Amin al-Husseini, a figure long venerated as an ideological lodestar, cemented this connection. In 1941, he met Hitler in Berlin, pledged Muslim support for the Nazi war effort, and returned to the Arab world broadcasting radio programs that fused Islamic symbolism with virulent Nazi antisemitism.
But the association went even further: Berlin’s SS formally structured military units recruiting Muslims. The most infamous was the 13th Waffen Mountain Division of the SS, Handschar (1st Croatian)—a combat formation composed largely of Bosnian Muslims, framed as the first non-Germanic Waffen-SS division. Soldiers donned fez hats alongside SS insignia and swore loyalty to both Hitler and Croatian fascist leader Pavelić.
There were even broader ambitions. Heinrich Himmler approved the formation of a second SS Muslim division—the 23rd Waffen Mountain Division, Kama—to neutralise Bosnian autonomist uprisings and extend Nazi control.
This was not marginal or opportunistic antisemitism—it was state-sanctioned, militarised, and institutionalised Jew-hatred. The Brotherhood’s hybrid of scripture and fascism carried institutional reverberations: SS brigades whose ideological forebears marched under the Brotherhood’s slogans.
And so when today’s campus activists traffic in conspiracies about “global Zionism,” it is not accidental, not a recycled cliché. These myths have their genesis in a sordid mid-century marriage of Islamist revival and Nazi totalitarianism.
Unlike al‑Qaeda’s spectacular nihilism, the Brotherhood advances through cultural infiltration, social services, and narrative capture.
The stages are depressingly consistent: establish cradle‑to‑grave institutions; rebrand political Islam as civil rights; monopolise Muslim representation; normalise sharia‑lite practices as cultural “accommodations.”
Mohamed-Ali Adraoui’s research refers to this as “entryism”: the exploitation of liberal institutions to hollow them out from within.
Pew data indicates that most Western Muslims reject violence — but this statistic is irrelevant. The Brotherhood thrives not on majorities but on monopolies: becoming the only voice that media and politicians heed.
In Canada, perhaps one in ten Muslims belongs to organised groups, yet those groups — MAC, NCCM, Islamic Relief — claim to speak for all. Secular, liberal, or ex‑Muslim voices are drowned out.
Europe is further along: Britain’s Muslim Association of Britain and France’s UOIF control hundreds of mosques, schools, and charities; surveys show 20–30 percent support sharia in family law. Canada, although numerically smaller, is, however, ideologically porous and naively multicultural.
This subtler jihad is more dangerous than bombs. Bombs provoke defence; narratives anaesthetise. A suicide attack triggers police raids; a lobbying campaign against “Islamophobia” triggers federal grants. One narrative horrifies; the other seduces—and seduction, over decades, always wins.
Islamophobia may well be the greatest marketing coup of the modern age: a single word that turns criticism of Islamist ideology into evidence of bigotry, makes secularists guilty until proven otherwise, and freezes debate on behalf of ideology.
It recasts political critique as a psychiatric disorder.
We are not phobic of anything—we are freedom-philic. We love liberty so fiercely that any ideology demanding self-censorship or moral surrender becomes our adversary.
And now comes the next conjuring trick: “anti-Palestinian racism.” Notice the sleight of hand—branding “Palestinian” as a race rather than a political identity. Historically, “Palestine” was a geographic designation. Under the British Mandate, “Palestinian” meant anyone residing in that territory: Jew, Christian, or Muslim alike. Golda Meir herself carried a Palestinian passport. Only in the mid-20th century, and especially post-1967, did the term harden into a nationalist self-identity. To retrofit it as race is not just ahistorical; it is disingenuous—crafted for ideological policing, not truth.
And what are the demands of this new catechism? That one must not criticise Hamas. That one must not mention the grotesque “martyr payments” for suicide bombers. That one must not raise a word about honour killings or theocratic sadism. To do so, we are told, is to commit a human rights violation, to be guilty of “hate speech.” It is, in every practical sense, the reintroduction of blasphemy law by a semantic backdoor.
The tactic is familiar: you don’t spread propaganda by shouting it louder; you spread it by forbidding rebuttal. For twenty months at the University of Guelph-Humber, I saw this applied in miniature. I was suspended without charges, branded a racist and a Nazi for criticising Hamas, and then, within hours, administrators, faculty, and staff fanned out across campus, whispering to students that I was a violent criminal, a paedophile, a man already under disciplinary review for years. Not a shred of it was true—but it did not have to be. For in the weeks that followed, my attempts to rebut these calumnies were reclassified as harassment. My pleas to stop the defamation were threats, I was told, of “criminal harassment.”
Why should a publicly funded institution, supposedly dedicated to inquiry, be allowed to silence dissent by turning rebuttal itself into an offence? If this is tolerated at a taxpayer-supported Canadian university, why would it not metastasise into society at large?
I do not recount this to wallow in self-pity but to show how the system works. What was done to me in a single workplace is the same method now being applied to an entire culture: scrape the internet for dissenters, invent defamatory charges, isolate them, and ensure they are forbidden from answering back.
The lie does not need to stand up—it only needs to go unanswered.
And that, precisely, is why they protect places like Guelph-Humber: because a silenced academic is a warning shot. Because if you can sack one professor for a LinkedIN response to some unknown radical in Pakistan, the next thousand will muzzle themselves without the need for written censorship codes.
The tyrants get their censorship, and they get it for free.
I was suspended without charges, branded a racist and a Nazi for criticising Hamas, and then, that very same evening, faculty and staff fanned out to students to declare me a violent criminal, a paedophile, a man already on the brink of dismissal.
The lies required no evidence; it was only that I be silenced. And all this was coming at me from a human rights complaint with the Claimant being the University Vice Provost, the equivalent of the President at the U of Guelph-Humber.
I never had a chance.
I recount this not to make it about me but to demonstrate how easily narrative control is exercised. What was done to me in a faculty office can be done to an entire culture.
Already, we see the same Brotherhood-derived tactic metastasising into campaigns to scrape the internet, to identify pro-Israel or Jewish voices in prominent (I can’t say I was prominent) or semi-prominent positions, and to destroy them through character assassination, pressure campaigns, and termination. It is not debate—it is prohibition. It is not persuasion—it is intimidation.
And here is the final genius of the scheme: the tyrant needn’t even legislate censorship. No law need be passed, no rule written in the books. All that is required is one public sacking, one professor fired, one critic destroyed.
After that, the rest of the herd learns the catechism by osmosis. The message is plain: watch what you say. And what does that mean in practice? Self-censorship. A servility so complete that the authorities needn’t even enforce it.
They want censorship, and they get it, not by decree but by fear. And the rest of us—students, journalists, academics—take the hint: dissent, and you too will be finished.
Universities remain the Brotherhood’s laboratories. The Muslim Students’ Association, founded by Brotherhood émigrés in the 1960s, begat Students for Justice in Palestine, which now choreographs encampments and “apartheid weeks” across North America.
Their graduates flow into NGOs, media, and politics — the conveyor belt that transforms radical slogans into policy orthodoxy.
Qatar bankrolls the infrastructure. A Yale report documented tens of millions in undeclared Qatari donations shaping campus discourse — funding endowed chairs, cultural centres, and fellowships that recast Hamas as “resistance” and Israel as apartheid. Canadian universities replicate the model through “Islamophobia studies” programs that immunise Brotherhood narratives from critique.
The future is bleaker still. The students chanting for intifada today will be tomorrow’s legislators, journalists, and corporate executives. Polls already show that half of North Americans under thirty sympathise more with Palestinians than with Israelis; one in five doubts or denies the Holocaust outright.
This is not a temporary convulsion but a generational shift.
The Brotherhood’s playbook — win the campuses, then win the culture, then write the laws — is working precisely as designed.
They have passed Phase One: embedding networks in universities and civil society. They are deep into Phase Two: normalising Islamist narratives as “social justice.”
Phase Three is dawning: translating these narratives into political power as graduates ascend to leadership. Their endgame, openly stated in al-Banna’s writings, remains a restored caliphate — not through conquest, but through consent, as Western societies slowly redefine surrender as a virtue.
Universities insist they are neutral, but neutrality is proven only in one direction: tolerance for anti‑Israel radicals, punishment for pro‑Israel dissenters. They are not overtly antisemitic; they simply enforce antisemitism’s outcomes.
The first step in resisting this drift is honesty: to say plainly that this is about Islam — not Muslims individually, but the political theology itself, its supremacist claims, its refusal to separate mosque from state. To critique Islamism while dancing around Islam is cowardice dressed up as nuance.
The next step is transparency — real transparency, not the cosmetic kind. Audit every foreign dollar. Name every donor. Strip bare the pious euphemisms about “cultural centres” and “foundations” bankrolled by petro‑theocracies. Politeness here is complicity.
Then comes courage — the unfashionable virtue without which every other principle is a pose. Defend secular norms without apology or genuflection. Understand that pluralism does not mean self‑annihilation, and that tolerance, if limitless, devours itself.
And above all, remember the pedigree of these Western freedoms we so casually inherit: they were not handed down by angels, but clawed into existence through centuries of struggle, martyrs’ stakes, and battlefields soaked in blood. To pretend otherwise is to invite their undoing.
The Brotherhood tends a garden of narratives, patiently awaiting harvest—Western democracies, entranced by their tolerance, mistake weeds for wildflowers. By the time they notice, the garden will no longer be theirs.
Bombs we can see. Narratives we inhale. And it is the narratives — polite, persistent, poisonous — that will decide whether the next century belongs to secular democracy or the slow suffocation of theocratic grievance.
If you’ve managed to stagger this far without hurling your laptop into the nearest pond — congratulations. Should you feel moved to reward such endurance, there’s a tip jar lurking nearby. It keeps the lights on.
So if you like your commentary unfocused-grouped and delivered without permission slips from the Ministry of Acceptable Opinions, well, you know what to do.











There is an ebb and flow to events and times and fact is the Muslims have the money, the numbers, and the higher birthrates. Most importantly, they don't apologize for what they believe or who they are. Whether or not All Praise to Allah will be added to the national anthems of western nations remains to be seen.
How many freedom-defending academics has illiberal academia slandered, pilloried and attempted to silence? Has anyone made a list? Here’s a start: Jordan Peterson, Eric Weinstein, Peter Boghossian (see https://www.thefp.com/p/my-university-sacrificed-ideas-for) and Paul Finlayson. Who can be add to this list?