Andrew Coyne’s column in the Globe and Mail rests, beneath all its arithmetic, on a single accusation: everybody who objects to excessive immigration is a racist. He never quite says the word — he is too practised for that — but it is the column’s whole argument, and everything else is decoration. From its first line to its last, the piece is an exercise in name-calling. This is a pity, because Mr. Coyne’s brand — the brand of forty years — is the voice of reason: the calm economist among the shouters. Read the column and count the reasons. His opponents are “hysterics.” Their concern is “whingeing,” their alarm a “theatrical rending of garments,” their information a “soup of online disinformation,” their real motive a secret appetite for deportation. The only surprise is the roll of villains he somehow left off: Mr. Poilievre and Mr. Trump escaped indictment this time, though one feels the omission was a matter of space. A voice of reason argues. A hysteric accuses.
And who delivers this lecture? A man born into incredible wealth and every connection Canada affords — a man who has in all likelihood never done his own grocery shopping — looking down on the hoi polloi: on people grousing about the price of groceries, about getting health care, about affording a house, about children who finished four years of university and cannot find work. None of these things has ever touched Andrew Coyne. None of them ever will. A man with a heart might meet such complaints with an argument, or at least with compassion. Mr. Coyne meets them with a shrug dressed as arithmetic. It is his Marie Antoinette moment. The people cannot afford the bread. Let them eat cake.
Before we come to the column, let us establish who is writing it.
Andrew Coyne was born in Ottawa in 1960, the son of James Elliott Coyne, Governor of the Bank of Canada. His great-grandfather was James Henry Coyne, the historian and lawyer. His cousin is Deborah Coyne, the constitutional lawyer from Rockcliffe Park, who summered at the family cottage on Meech Lake and who is the mother of Pierre Trudeau’s daughter — which is to say that Andrew Coyne is a cousin of Justin Trudeau. His classmates at Trinity College included a founder of BlackBerry, a future chief of staff to a prime minister, and Malcolm Gladwell. He took his master’s degree at the London School of Economics, and then he ascended, without interruption and without friction, through every commanding height of Canadian journalism: the Financial Post, the Globe and Mail, Maclean’s, the National Post, the CBC, and back to the Globe again.
There is nothing shameful in any of this. A man is not responsible for his grandfather. But a man is responsible for what his life has taught him, and Andrew Coyne’s life has taught him nothing about the subjects on which he now lectures the country. Do you really think Andrew Coyne has ever had trouble finding a family doctor? Do you really think the Coyne family sits in a waiting room? He has never watched a child of his fail to find an entry-level job in a market flooded at the bottom. The odds that Mr. Coyne has ever been touched by a thirteen-hour wait in an emergency room are about the odds that Mr. Carney has, or Mr. Trudeau. Men like these are not failed by the system. The system is theirs. He is as entitled as Justin Trudeau, and for the same reason: the country has always worked for him, so he assumes it works.
Last week Mr. Coyne wrote a column in the Globe and Mail — “The real immigration ‘fib’?” — accusing critics of the federal budget of lying about immigration. The budget grants permanent residence to up to 200,000 temporary residents already in Canada, on top of the annual target of 380,000, for a total of 662,000 new permanent residents in 2027. Mr. Coyne’s defence is arithmetic. A conversion is not an arrival, he says. These people are already here. Giving them different papers adds, in his words, “not one ounce” to the pressures on housing, health care, and jobs. The real number of newcomers will be 200,000 or so — “about the same as under Stephen Harper.” Canada’s population grew by only 190,000 last year, the slowest rate in our history. The public, he concludes, is calm about all this. The backlash is a fiction of Conservative politicians and the “soup of online disinformation.”
Notice what the arithmetic conceals. It conceals it in his own column. Mr. Coyne concedes — buries, rather, in a subordinate clause — that in the surge years the government “had clearly lost control of a couple of the student and temporary worker programs,” and that he himself believed there was too much immigration in those years. Stop there. The loss of control is admitted by the columnist who calls everyone else a liar. Millions arrived in a handful of years through programs the government had lost control of. And the question before the country now is what to do about that fact. Mr. Coyne’s answer is: nothing. Ratify it. Convert it. Make it permanent, and call the bookkeeping honesty.
Immigration pressure is like inflation. The government boasts that inflation is going down, and so it is — but the bread that cost five dollars and went up to six dollars has not gone back to five dollars. It never does. A falling rate is not a falling price. The people who arrived in 2023 and 2024 are still here. They are in the rental market, which is a price, not a rate. They are in the emergency rooms. They are in the queue for the entry-level jobs that Canada’s young people cannot find — youth unemployment stands at 13.7 per cent — and converting their status does not remove one ounce of that pressure. It locks the new price level in and forbids anyone to name it. Mr. Coyne’s “not one ounce” is true for exactly one day: the day the papers are signed. Every day after that, the ounce is on the scale, and it stays there, because the people stay there. That is the whole point of the measure. It is also the whole point he will not say.
There is a question underneath the arithmetic that Mr. Coyne never asks: what does this teach? A temporary permit is a promise — you may come for this purpose, for this long, on these terms. Hundreds of thousands of people are now in Canada on permits that are expiring, and a great many of them are simply declining to go home. The government’s answer, blessed by Mr. Coyne, is to convert them. Consider the lesson as it will be received by every student and worker now deciding whether to honour the terms of his visa, and by every applicant abroad deciding whether to bother with the queue at all. The lesson is that the terms are fiction. Stay long enough, put down roots, organize, wait for the politics to ripen, and the paper will follow. Mr. Coyne’s counsel to the country is serenity: do not worry about enforcing the law, do not worry about the terms of the visa — give them permanent residence and call the surrender compassion. A state that will not enforce the conditions of its own hospitality has not reformed its immigration system. It has abolished the word “temporary” without a vote, and replaced the law with a lottery in which the prize goes to whoever ignores the law longest.
He will not say a good deal. His column is a sermon about honesty in numbers that never mentions the asylum system at all. In 2024, 22,245 people who had entered Canada on study permits filed asylum claims — a record. In 2025, nearly twenty thousand more. The refugee board’s backlog stands at roughly 298,000 claims, with years to wait for a hearing. The share of student claimants who waited more than a year after arriving before claiming rose from 11 per cent to 38 per cent in a single year: asylum is being used, openly, as a device to extend a stay that has expired. Some seven hundred Punjabi students faced deportation in 2023 because their admission letters were forged by an agent; a federal task force examined more than two thousand such cases. Of all this — the fraud, the backlog, the queue-jumping that poisons the public’s faith in the genuine refugee’s claim — the Governor’s son has nothing to say. A column about the immigration “fib” that omits the asylum channel entirely is not an argument. It is a selection.
I write with an interest Mr. Coyne cannot declare. Immigration is not an abstraction in my house. My wife was not born in Canada. Neither was my son. My wife was a neurologist in Russia, and when we were to marry, in the early 2000s, Canada would not give her a temporary visa to come here for the wedding. A neurologist — a woman this country now trusts with its sick — was treated as a risk, and so she stayed where she was, and waited, and came at last on a spousal visa, and then requalified in her profession from the ground up. That is what the system demanded of an honest applicant, and she paid it in full.
Set that beside the system Mr. Coyne blesses. Cheat on the English test. Arrive unable to speak the language. Be passed through some second-rate college that sells a diploma to a man who cannot write a sentence, and work under the table — exploited, very often, by your own compatriots, who know exactly how little you can complain. And when the permit expires and someone finally tells you to go home, discover the refugee claim: a persecution in the Punjab, founded on a homosexuality discovered very lately and unmentioned until the letter arrived — which, the claim once granted, will soften into bisexuality just in time for the wife to be sponsored. Lovely.
My family came the way the rules demanded. The dodge comes the way the rules permit. Mr. Coyne’s serenity blesses the second and steps over the first.
I have friends — Indian Canadians who practise immigration law, in firms that do little but refugee claims for Indian students — who describe the pattern I have just set out with a weariness that is almost comedy. The persecution was a costume; the sexuality was a form to fill in; and everyone in the system knows it, and the file moves on, because the file always moves on. I do not blame the claimant alone. A system that advertises that its rules are decorative will be gamed by rational people, and the gaming is the system’s confession. But let the cost be named: every fraudulent claim that succeeds is taken out of the hide of a genuine refugee — the man or woman in actual danger whose place in the queue, and whose share of the public’s finite compassion, is spent by the dodge ahead of them. Canada cannot take in every refugee from every country in turmoil; the world’s turmoil is bottomless. A system that cannot say no to the costume cannot protect the real thing. And a columnist who will not look at the costume is not defending refugees. He is spending them.
And consider the sentence at the column’s heart, the one Mr. Coyne plainly thinks is his kindness showing. The 200,000, he writes, are people “with jobs and homes and kids in school” who would no longer live “under the shadow of deportation” but could build their lives “in the country they chose from all over the world in which to make their home.” Chose. There are 117.8 million forcibly displaced people on this earth, by the United Nations’ count — a population approaching three Canadas. Every one of them would choose, if choosing were the criterion. A country is not a hotel that fills by self-selection. The queue exists because the world is larger than the lifeboat, and the people in the queue — the ones who applied, and waited, and were vetted, like my wife, who immigrated to Canada and requalified as a physician from the ground up — are the ones this policy steps over. Nobody is proposing to deport Hong Kong graduates or Ukrainian families, and Mr. Coyne knows it; letting a temporary permit expire on its own terms is not deportation, and his repeated reach for the word is the tell. When the argument runs out, the accusation begins: his critics are innumerate, or secretly hungry for mass deportations, or marinated in disinformation. There is no fourth possibility in his world — that a citizen might count the rent, and the wait, and his son’s empty inbox of job replies, and conclude that the country took in more people than it could house, heal, or employ, and that a government which lost control should regain it rather than consecrate the loss.
And notice the flags he waves while he makes it. Hong Kong. Ukraine. The shadow of deportation hangs over his column — it is the insinuation on which his whole moral case rests — and it covers a quarter of his subject. By the government’s own figures, the Hong Kong pathways account for up to 32,000 of the 200,000; the Ukraine pathway for up to 18,800. Together, 50,800: one in four. The other three quarters of the measure — a hundred thousand workers, and the balance of the humanitarian cohort, whose full breakdown the government has never published — Mr. Coyne does not describe at all. A recitation of the numbers that recites only the quarter that serves the argument is not an error; it is a dishonest recitation. A columnist who opens by accusing his opponents of cooking the books owes his readers the whole recipe. He serves them the garnish and calls it the meal.
And consider who is serving it. A regal Canadian blue blood — a governor’s son, a prime minister’s cousin — with no connection to immigration at all: no wife who waited abroad for a spousal visa because a temporary one was refused her, no one in his house who ever stood in the queue he blesses. From that altitude he sneers at the father whose daughter is six months out of university and has not had a single interview, at the family counting a rent it cannot pay, and he finds the only explanation his class keeps in stock: racist. Hysteric. Marinated in disinformation. He is not mistaken, and he is not confused. A man who buries his own concession in a subordinate clause, waves a quarter of a measure as though it were the whole of it, and answers his countrymen’s arithmetic with an accusation of bigotry is not erring. He is lying.
Mr. Coyne assures us the harms are imaginary. House prices, he notes, rose from the year 2000 and have fallen from their 2022 peak. House prices. The family in the rental queue does not live in a house price; it lives in a rent, and rents have fallen from no peak. And on the substance he is contradicted by the very authorities his class treats as oracles. The Bank of Canada has said the surge added to the demand for housing faster than supply could answer. The housing agency’s own economists have written that record population growth intensified the strain. And the minister who presided over the surge justified cutting the temporary-resident share of the population to five per cent precisely on the ground that housing and services could not keep up. When the central bank concedes the pressure, and the housing agency concedes it, and the government itself concedes it, the columnist who waves it away is not correcting a fib. He is telling one.
Even his polling betrays him. He cites Environics to prove the public is calm: the share saying there is “too much immigration” has fallen from 58 per cent to 48 per cent. Forty-eight per cent is not calm. It is half the country, after the levels were cut — and it was 35 per cent in 2019, before the surge. Opinion follows levels, in his own data, in his own column. The public is not hysterical and it is not phlegmatic. It is doing what it always does: watching what is done to its neighbourhoods and drawing the obvious conclusion, while the Laurentian elite explains that the conclusion is a character flaw.
That is the real subject of Mr. Coyne’s column, and it is why his biography is not a digression but the argument. The Laurentian consensus was never a consensus. It was an arrangement among people who summered on the same lake, governed the same bank, and married into the same families, to decide the country’s questions among themselves and to treat every objection from outside the arrangement as a defect of the objector — his arithmetic, his motives, his sources of information. The arrangement is now in its third generation and it has not changed its method. It has only changed its subject. Once it was the constitution. Now it is the border.
Mr. Coyne is right about one thing, and he should be given it plainly: a status conversion is not a new arrival, and anyone who adds the 200,000 to the 380,000 and calls it 662,000 newcomers at the airport is wrong. But the number of new permanent residents Canada grants in a year is not a fib either — it is 662,000, a record, granted by a government that promised restraint, to a population admitted under programs its own defenders concede were out of control. The honest sentence is not hard to write. Mr. Coyne will not write it, because writing it would require admitting that the people outside the arrangement — the ones in the waiting rooms and the rental queues — saw something real, and saw it before he did.
Stop lying, Mr. Coyne. Not about the arithmetic. About the country.




I wonder if The Star would print this brilliant response
This kind of explains why elementary school history lessons no longer mention the Family Compact or Le Chateau Clique, the Laurentian elites that ran Canada for their own benefit before Confederation. They just flushed them down the memory hole and rebranded as the LPC. Though nowadays it’s looking like a majority interest in the Party has been sold to the CCP, with Qatar holding a small slice, and the Compradors themselves the remainder.