6 Comments
User's avatar
Harry's avatar

As that wry observer of political science, Peter Townsend, once wrote, “Here comes the new boss, same as the old boss.” At least with Justin, you could assume it was stupidity and incompetence, rather than evil.

Freedom To Offend's avatar

Yes. I wish people knew that degrees and being meaningfully educated are not the same thing

L.G. Oja's avatar

Like your critique of Carney is spot on.

In my 55 odd years of working experience, the dumbest people, when it came to logic and common sense with mechanical processes, had a PhD on their wall.

The two smartest co-workers that could analytically detail multiple layers of engineering fundamentals, in “layman’s terms,” redressing the “academic elites” technologic precepts, -had a formal education to grade six.

A piece of paper does not engender expertise or intelligence.

L.G. Oja's avatar

Farmers have a “lived experience” based in the realities of sustaining life. Their career is very, very challenging.

The North American precept favours academia over trade journeymen.

In most European countries one has to have his “trade” as a prerequisite to an advanced degree.

Having worked with engineers educated in both systems; I favour the European system.

A Journeyman certificate being based on actual hands on experience under guidance, supplemented by classroom theory , provides for a superior capability.

I and, my family, too have farmed and ranched, part of my life I value. A kid who has his ass drug from bed at 05:00 to get his chores done before breakfast and school, has very useful life experience.

Couple that with post secondary, a trade, and then a degree and you have a rare employment asset, in high demand, that will rise up through the ranks on competency and merit.

I enjoy your essays.

Freedom To Offend's avatar

I heard that farmers make the best engineers

Freedom To Offend's avatar

I agree. My dad was a PhD who was a farmer much of his life. If you need a decision made and you have five farmers or five professors? Who do you choose. Not a serious question. Farmers going away.